Ten Commandments/Rules/Guidelines for Writing Fiction
“
A story is a way to say something that can’t be said any other way, and it takes every word in the story to say what the meaning is.” Flannery O’Connor
I know there’s a big risk to naming a set of rules after the Ten Commandments. The commandments are supposedly indelible, sacred, and potent. Live this way and you’ll be a good person. Mess up and you’re immoral or doomed. Most of the commandments come easy for many of us—we joke about murdering someone, but when push comes to shove, we’ll probably just complain to our best friend instead of slipping the object of our ire some arsenic. That’s why we write.
And there are other problems in declaring that there are ten rules or guidelines for writing fiction. Some people claim rules are nonsense, some that there are too many to list, and of course, you’ll find little agreement about the so-called rules. This was in evidence in
The Guardian’s recent article about the 10 Rules of Writing Fiction. In the article Elmore Leonard claims writers should never use prologues, but some of my favorite books begin with prologues and I wrote a whole chapter on the topic in Between the Lines. However, I do agree that dialogue tags should be invisible, adverbs are unnecessary, and to avoid using ‘suddenly’ and exclamation points. At the same time, I love Margaret Atwood’s advice “You most likely need a thesaurus, a rudimentary grammar book, and a grip on reality.” And I dare not argue with Roddy Doyle’s sage advice: “Do not place a photograph of your ¬favourite author on your desk, especially if the author is one of the famous ones who committed suicide.”
With that said, I’m going to weigh in on heavier matters of fiction writing. Even though writers sometimes dislike rules, fiction requires underpinnings and archetypes to hold it together. And if you don’t understand the basics of writing fiction, while you can accomplish a lot of typing, a break-your-heart-hold-your-interest-story, the sort that makes readers weep at the wonder and mystery of it, doesn’t always result. And memoir and nonfiction writers, much of this applies to you too because
STORIES LEAVE OUT THE BORING PARTS OF LIFE.
I. Always remember that your first job is to be a storyteller. Begin with a compelling hook that pulls the reader into the story, squirming with anticipation, raises questions and starts the reader worrying and wondering about the protagonist. The best hooks involve an inciting incident—an event that changes a character’s status, creates stress, and inflicts threatening changes to his or her situation. So typically you open a story by plunging into action and generally avoid writing a lot of description or background information. Now, that last bit said, plenty of great stories begin with description, but if you start this way it needs to evoke a mood and serve several purposes while introducing the story world.
II. Instill in your protagonist believable and powerful motivations. Desire is the heartbeat of fiction and typically it should be a deeply-felt need or desire that is somehow linked with the protagonist’s past. Often the best way to understand a character’s motivation is to determine what they fear most. Is it losing his marriage or job? Or harm coming to her children? Use that fear as the threat that propels him to act, sometimes recklessly or blindly.
III. Bestow your main characters with dominant, unforgettable traits that are the basis for their personalities and will be showcased by the events of the story.
These traits will help them achieve goals and provide consistency. Then stir in flaws, emotional needs, and weaknesses that are integral to the plot, should be overcome, transformed or acknowledged by the end of the story. Use drama, action and dialogue to expose to your character’s traits, needs, and flaws and prove that he can change or triumph. Unless you’re writing a tragedy in which you prove that your character’s flaws or a stacked deck cannot be overcome.
IV. Remember that fiction is based on cause and effect. The inciting incident starts a chain of events, which causes the characters to react, which causes more events, causing more reaction and actions. However, this doesn’t mean your protagonist is merely reactive. As the story progresses, he’s taking charge, setting goals, rising to challenges. This whole chain continues until the climax, which is of course generated by the characters’ actions.
V. Note that fiction is fueled by conflict, which in turn creates suspense and tension. Conflict, usually in the form of opposition, especially opposing agendas held by the cast of characters, should appear on every page, in every scene and keeps readers turning the pages. Your characters should confront a host of obstacles, and be in conflict with each other, themselves, and the world. Try impaling your characters on the horns of a dilemma—the “dammed if you do, dammed if you don’t” kind is especially involving.
VI. Dramatize your fiction and memoir. This means that you will shape most themes and character growth into scenes. Scenes are the building blocks of fiction and memoir and most scenes contain opposition, and move your protagonist closer or farther away from his or her fate. When possible, orchestrate emotional reversal in your scenes meaning that the emotions felt in the opening of the scene, should differ from those at the end of the scene. A character starts out feeling hopeful and ends up feeling dismay or hopeless. Scenes expose the emotional life and struggles of the characters. Scenes either advance the plot, provide background information, or throw obstacles at the characters. They are never used as filler or to prop up a sagging plot.
VII. Write scenes that occur in a specific time and place. Include setting that depicts weather, lighting, evidence of the time of day and season. On a large scale setting will include region, geography, towns, neighborhoods, streets, buildings, shops, schools, restaurants, parks, rivers, creeks, lakes, oceans. Setting also includes interiors including furniture, windows, clutter, dust bunnies, knickknacks and collections. Remember that these ordinary and homey details cause the reader to believe in your make-believe world, and thus make the extraordinary events of your plot more believable because the story is steeped in objects and places from everyday life.
VIII. Use plot points and a mid-point reversal to push the story forward and keep the reader engaged. I like to think of a plot point as a one-way gate through which a character passes. Each plot point is a catalyst for more action. Once through the gate, there is no turning back and the character is spun around, ending up dizzy and off balance. A plot point is always a major event, a high point or milestone, always has consequences and an emotional charge, and pushes the plot ahead.
IX. Give your plot a “dark night of the soul” moment near the climax. This is the point where the situation is bleakest—the odds are stacked against the protagonist, the dangers appear deadly, the way out non-existent. However, the way out of the dark night involves overcoming flaws or perceived weaknesses and relying on positive traits that gave the readers hope and reasons to cheer the protagonist all along. The dark night of the soul should include the character’s last-ditch and mightiest effort to solve the story problem and achieve his goals. And finally, the dark night of the soul is where the character is questioning whether this has all been worth it. Has he or she done the right thing, made the right decisions?
X. Create an ending that provides resolution, an emotional highpoint for the characters, an emotional release for readers, and a backward, illuminating glance at the previous events. Unless you’ve landed a six-book deal, avoid ‘open’ endings because they’re difficult to write and because readers long for a sense of completion. In real life we often slog through our routines and numbing jobs, and there is often not enough sense of completion, of justice served, of release. Good story endings provide that catharsis and enjoyment, so plan and orchestrate your ending with care. When you write memoir endings avoid both vagueness and trying to tidy up your story or nail down the story with broad insights. Often life doesn’t provide easy answers, but all we can do is sort through things and admit to regrets and patterns and influences.