In going where you have to go, and doing what you have to do, and seeing what you have to see, you dull and blunt the instrument you write with. But I would rather have it bent and dull and know I had to put it on the grindstone again and hammer it into shape and put a whetstone to it, and know that I had something to write about, than to have it bright and shining and nothing to say, or smooth and well-oiled in the closest but unused.
Ernest Hemmingway
The sky looks like a Renaissance painting this morning with sunlight diffusing the clouds as if a great being might appear or a magical creature might swoop down from the heavens, offering miracles. Protestors have dumped red dye into the Willamette River today –they’re carrying “no more blood for oil” signs and explaining that a quarter of every tax dollar we pay goes to fund the occupation in Iraq. Not to mention that we’re borrowing $1 billion a day to keep the government afloat. Today there was a moment of silence in Israel to pay respect to the 6 million Jews who were killed in the Holocaust. Perhaps some day we can have a moment of silence to honor all the soldiers and Iraqi civilians, the women the children and shopkeepers and policemen who have been killed in this catastrophic and greed-based power grab.
On Saturday I taught a workshop on narrative nonfiction and wanted to pass along some of the narrative techniques we talked about. First, the terms creative nonfiction, literary nonfiction and narrative nonfiction are used interchangeably these days. Whatever you call it, this hybrid form of nonfiction, as opposed to reports or journalism, doesn’t just report facts, it delivers facts in ways that move the reader to a deeper understanding of a topic, often evoking emotions in the reader. Creative or narrative nonfiction might be a single essay or compilations of articles and essays and book-length memoirs. Narrative nonfiction goes beyond the expression of the self, it is a thoughtful search for truth, and is based on themes. The personal experiences should connect with readers, and usually include some kind of research. Narrative nonfiction also includes such fiction techniques as dialogue, description, viewpoint and character development to tell the story.
In writing narrative nonfiction a writer employs the analysis and diligence of a reporter, the voice and viewpoints of a novelist, and the imagery and wordplay of a poet The best narrative nonfiction embraces a larger audience and strikes a universal chord.
So here are techniques for making nonfiction as dynamic, involving and suspenseful as fiction.
1. Open with a hook and if possible open with some sort of motion if possible. While summary openings can work, remember that readers prefer to be witnesses, watch an action unfold in front of them. The beginning's job is to lure—you want to entice the reader into the story and then deliver on that enticement. At the same time you have some logistics to deal with, like introducing people, setting and possibly conflict.
2. Show, don’t tell by dramatizing whenever possible and summarizing and reporting only as necessary. The creative nonfiction writer aims to be an eyewitness on the scene. Writing in scenes in the cinematographer’s close up shot, summary, in contrast, summary is like a long shot or wide angle. Readers trust the close up more than the long shot.
Because scenes happen in the moment and unfold in front of the reader, they create worry and involvement. Scenes are the building blocks of stories, including nonfiction. A scene makes the past present and engages the senses, particularly when it includes conversation because sound focuses the reader’s attention. Scenes are involving because as in fiction they are built on a pattern of conflict and often include some form of emotional reversal. Scenes involve the reader’s emotions and he accepts the narrative information as true when it’s embedded in a scene. You can also slip in descriptions of people and setting amid conversations and actions.
As you’re creating a story, look for events and incidents with the most dramatic potential, the moments that most reveal people. Here are examples of moments that you’ll want to stage:
births showdowns deaths
flashbacks arguments hardships
triumphs disasters life reversals
beginnings failures turning points
decisions choices regrets
epiphanies realizations no- turning-back moments
endings losses lies
accidents violence meetings
3. Narrative nonfiction contains artful language. This vivid language uses potent verbs, unexpected images and word combinations and figurative language to tell true stories. Here is an example from George Plimpton’s Paper Lion: “I came off the bench slowly, working my fingers up into my helmet to get at my ears. As I crossed the sidelines I was conscious then only of moving into the massive attention of the crowd, but seeing ahead out of the opening of my helmet the two teams waiting. Some of the defense were already kneeling at the line of scrimmage, their heads turned so that helmeted, sliver, with the cages protruding they were made to seem animal and impersonal--wildlife of some large species disturbed at a waterhole—watching me come toward them.”
4. Embedded with realistic and powerful details. Details nail down the abstract and help readers conjure up his or her memories, and enable readers to understand new ideas. But the writer is always selective when choosing which details to use and which to leave out. Details should effect the outcome of the piece and make readers understand meaning and themes. We embed our writing with specific details because we want our words to enter the reader’s heart and mind, invade the senses, stir memories, and creep into his or her imagination. In Painted Paragraphs Donald Newlove writes, “Good description shakes us. It fills our lungs with the life of its author. Suddenly, he sings within us. Someone has seen life as we see it! And the voice that fills us, should the writer be dead, bridges the gulf between life and death. Great description is stronger than death.” If the selection of details is accurate and potent, the writer won’t need a lot of explanations to prove what he or she means. Excessive commentary can become intrusive and is a form to telling.
6. Often narrative nonfiction is based on a specific topic (such as the sort of books written by John McPhee or Tracy Kidder) or a person under close scrutiny. No matter if the topic, it always examines the private lives and realities of individuals. If you’re writing about nature or ecological disasters, the human intersection in these topics must also be present.
7. Bring people to life and make the reader feel as he is in the room using dialogue. People are most exposed and real when they’re talking. Readers lean in when a conversation happens, especially if it’s an argument, power exchange, or if underlined with subtext—the river of emotion that flows beneath scenes but cannot be expressed outright. Always pay close attention to what people say and how they say it. Notice regional and local variations of speech and idiom. If the person is a specialist or expert, such as a detective, athlete, scientist, use his jargon to show his specialized knowledge or skill.
8. The writer’s voice simmers behind and within the words and is memorable, distinctive and authentic. Voice is the writer’s breath of life. Lewis Lapham, editor of Harpers explains his position on voice: “On first opening a book I listen for the sound of the human voice. By this device I am absolved from reading much of what is published in a given year. Most writers make use of institutional codes (academic, literary, political, bureaucratic, technical), in which they send messages already deteriorating into the half-life of yesterday’s news. Their transmissions remain largely unintelligible, and unless I must decipher them for professional reasons, I am content to let them pass by. I listen, instead, for a voice in which I can hear the music of human improvisation as performed through 5,000 years on the stage of recorded time…..As a student, and later as an editor and occasional writer of reviews, I used to feel obligated to finish every book I began to read. This I no longer do. If within the first few pages I cannot hear the author’s voice….I abandon him at the first convenient opportunity.”